[Defeated] Repeal "Restrictions On Hydraulic Fracturing"

[Cormac]

Repeal "Restrictions On Hydraulic Fracturing"

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.

Category: Repeal | Resolution: GA#417 | Proposed by: Imperium Anglorum

---

General Assembly Resolution #417 “Restrictions on Hydraulic Fracturing” (Category: Environmental; Industry Affected: All Businesses) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The General Assembly,

Believing that:

1. it is not fracking, but rather, the improper disposal of well fluids, which leads to groundwater contamination and induced seismic activity, something which intuitively makes sense, since near-impermeable rocks thousands of metres below the surface have little ability to change surface-level groundwater compositions and large underground disposals of fluids can change geological conditions, respectively, and
2. binding international law should regulate the proximate cause of harms, rather than cast about wildly for actions to prohibit, thereby creating unintended consequences,

Concerned that this resolution fails to regulate well fluid disposal directly, but rather, seeks to prohibit in many areas, hydraulic fracturing, making it extremely difficult for society to achieve compelling public policy interests such as:

1. providing well-paying jobs to national citizens, helping them earn income to feed their families, invest in their children, save for their retirements, and make capital investments, building a more dynamic and prosperous economy as a whole,
2. self-sufficiency in fuel production, thereby preventing a society from having to rely on possibly unscrupulous, exploitative, oppressive, or hostile foreign actors to provide vital fuels that would require them to be complicit in morally repugnant activities,
3. production of natural resources for the benefit of tax revenues that can then be used to vital development investments to build infrastructure, highways, railroads, public housing, schools, etc., benefiting a whole society's quality of life and wealth, and
4. development of technologies (i) vital to natural gas extraction to bridge from more pollutive fossil fuels towards future renewable energy sources and (ii) lower natural gas prices relative to other fossil fuels, producing economic incentives towards fully mature and comparatively cleaner energy sources, thereby helping to mitigate the existential threat of carbon dioxide-driven climate change,

Hereby repeals GA c. 417 "Restrictions on Hydraulic Fracturing".

[Cormac]

1. I opposed this resolution, so it makes sense to support its repeal.
2. Fracking really isn't an international issue, so the NatSov in me doesn't want the WA regulating it.
3. Imperium Anglorum knows his stuff, so if he says it should be repealed, I tend to agree.
4. Unfortunately, it should be noted repeal is failing by a pretty good margin with less than two days remaining.

Still, Aye vote from me.

[The Atlae Isles]

Against.

[Mike]

Aye

[Cormac]

"Repeal "Restrictions on Hydraulic Fracturing"" was defeated 10,882 votes to 6,572.