Category: Repeal
Resolution: GA#342
Proposed by: Bitely
General Assembly Resolution #342 “Civilian Aircraft Accord” (Category: International Security; Strength: Mild) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.
APPLAUDS the good intentions of this assembly for recognizing that "it is the duty of all nations to protect the lives of innocent civilians";
NOTING that this resolution was intended "to enact a sensible policy that allows for the safe and secure" oversight of civilian aircraft;
ALARMED that clause 2 section C requires member states to provide "Assistance to any civilian aircraft that declares itself to be in distress" even if there is sufficient evidence that the civilian aircraft is not in distress;
FURTHER alarmed that clause 2 section C requires member states to assist civilian aircraft in the airspace of potentially hostile neighbor nations airspace as long as it's "within ... communication range";
REALIZING clause 2 section C unintentionally opens up both member states military and civilian first responders to possible malicious enemy military action by requiring them to assist an enemy "civilian" aircraft potentially in hostile territory even if the call of distress is suspicious;
BELIEVING that by clause 2 section C requiring members to respond to all distress calls made by "civilian" aircraft within communication range, which could include hostile territory, this resolution has failed to enact a "sensible policy";
HEREBY this Assembly REPEALS "Civilian Aircraft Accord"
[AT VOTE] Repeal: "Civilian Aircract Accord"
Archive of General Assembly proposal discussion threads.
Moderators: Pharaoh, Sub-Vizier, Vizier, Chief Vizier
- Midnight Sparkle
- Diplomat
- Posts: 340
- Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2018 12:00 am
- Contact:
[AT VOTE] Repeal: "Civilian Aircract Accord"
Post by Midnight Sparkle »
Vizier of World Assembly Affairs
- Midnight Sparkle
- Diplomat
- Posts: 340
- Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2018 12:00 am
- Contact:
Re: [AT VOTE] Repeal: "Civilian Aircract Accord"
Post by Midnight Sparkle »
Personally against, given the author is Bitely and it is poorly written in general (unfounded fears of sneak attacks from saving people).
Vizier of World Assembly Affairs
Jump to
- Applications and Introductions
- ↳ Hall of the Ogdoad
- Community and Culture
- ↳ Temple of Bes
- ↳ Osiran Historical Library
- ↳ General Archive
- ↳ Temple of Khepri
- ↳ OOC Info and Help Desk
- ↳ Character Roleplay
- ↳ Role Play Archive
- ↳ Great Cities Archive
- ↳ Active Cities Archive
- ↳ Thebes Archive
- ↳ Karnak Archive
- ↳ Terenuthis Archive
- ↳ Philae Archive
- ↳ Kadesh Archive
- ↳ The Arcane City of Abydos
- ↳ Palace of the North
- ↳ The Ancient City of Memphis
- ↳ The Royal Palace of Pharaohs
- ↳ The Osiran Shaperate
- ↳ The Great City of Giza
- ↳ The Palace of BrightAxe
- ↳ The Enlightened City of Alexandria
- ↳ Castle Ravenclaw
- ↳ Great Cities of Osiris
- ↳ The Royal Capital of Thebes
- ↳ Sethos Palace
- ↳ The Temple City of Karnak
- ↳ Stark Basilica
- ↳ The Fortress City of Terenuthis
- ↳ Montresor Citadel
- ↳ The Holy Island of Philae
- ↳ Dreizehn Stronghold
- ↳ The Frontier City of Kadesh
- ↳ Denral Fortress
- ↳ World RP
- ↳ Factbooks
- ↳ Osiris Legends
- ↳ Cartography
- ↳ Diplomacy, War, & Trade
- ↳ Factbooks & Characters
- ↳ Recent Happenings
- ↳ OsiMT
- ↳ Shrines of Nekhen
- ↳ The Nekhen Grand Plaza
- ↳ The Church of the Holy Thirteen
- ↳ The Grand Temple of Flemingovia
- ↳ The Memorial Gardens of Nekhen
- ↳ The Land of Osiris
- ↳ Lorebooks
- ↳ Temple of Nun
- ↳ Spam Archive
- State and Government
- ↳ Palace of the Pharaoh
- ↳ Hall of Osiris
- ↳ Shrine of Nekhbet
- ↳ Pharaoh's Archive
- ↳ Hall of Ma'at
- ↳ Judicial Archive
- ↳ Temple of Nephythys
- ↳ Shrine of Ptah
- ↳ Community Affairs Archive
- ↳ Shrine of Hathor
- ↳ Diplomatic Documents
- ↳ Foreign Affairs Archive
- ↳ Shrine of Khnum
- ↳ Gameside Affairs Archive
- ↳ Shrine of Apis
- ↳ The Osiris Oracle
- ↳ Osiran Media
- ↳ Foreign Media
- ↳ Media Archive
- ↳ Osiran Media Archive
- ↳ Foreign Media Archive
- ↳ Media Subforums Archive
- ↳ Osiran Broadcasting Corporation
- ↳ The Osiris Oracle 1.0
- ↳ The Osiris Outlaw
- ↳ The Applebanian Post
- ↳ Pacific News Network
- ↳ The Rejected Times
- ↳ The Runes
- ↳ The Victor Siege Report
- ↳ Shrine of Amun-Ra
- ↳ WA Archive
- ↳ Shrine of Amun
- ↳ Shrine of Ra
- ↳ Vizier Archive
- ↳ Temple of Sekhmet
- ↳ Legion Archive
- ↳ Osiran Law Index
- ↳ Diplomatic Documents
- ↳ Voting Archive
- ↳ Temple of Hapi
- ↳ Allied Embassies
- ↳ The Black Hawks
- ↳ The Brotherhood of Malice
- ↳ The Rejected Realms
- ↳ Non-Allied Embassies
- ↳ Hartfelden
- ↳ Kantrias
- ↳ Karma
- ↳ Consulates
- ↳ Embassy Archive
- ↳ Consulates Archive
- ↳ Ainur
- ↳ Albion
- ↳ The Allied States
- ↳ Alvaris Confederation
- ↳ Antarctic Oasis
- ↳ Arda en Estel
- ↳ Balder
- ↳ Caprecia and Nysa
- ↳ The Coalition of Democratic Nations
- ↳ The Communist Bloc
- ↳ Democratic Republic of Bavaria
- ↳ DEN
- ↳ The East Pacific
- ↳ The Empire of Mare Nostrum
- ↳ Equilism
- ↳ Equinox
- ↳ The Eternal Knights
- ↳ Europe
- ↳ Europeia
- ↳ Firehelm
- ↳ The Galactic Order
- ↳ Global Right Alliance
- ↳ Grand Central
- ↳ HYDRA Command
- ↳ Independent Order
- ↳ International Democratic Union
- ↳ Kingdom of Alexandria
- ↳ The Kingdom of Great Britain
- ↳ La France
- ↳ The Land of Kings and Emperors
- ↳ Lazarus
- ↳ The League
- ↳ Lone Wolves United
- ↳ Madrigal
- ↳ Mazeria
- ↳ Mordor
- ↳ The New Galactic Empire
- ↳ The New Inquisition
- ↳ The North Pacific
- ↳ Oyashima
- ↳ Pacifica
- ↳ The Pacific
- ↳ The South Pacific
- ↳ Spiritus
- ↳ Taijitu
- ↳ The Universal Allegiance
- ↳ Vvardenfell
- ↳ Yggdrasil
- ↳ The West Pacific
- ↳ United Kingdom
- Technical and Archives
- ↳ Temple of Atum
- Forum Archives
- ↳ Temple of Anubis
- ↳ OFO 2.0 (Scroll of Horus)
- ↳ Treaty Law Index
- ↳ Historical Library Archives
- ↳ OFO 2.0 (Scroll of Ma'at)
- ↳ Palace of the Scribes
- ↳ Chief Scribe's Courtyard
- ↳ Voting Floor
- ↳ Election Precinct
- ↳ Voting Archive
- ↳ Legislative Archive
- ↳ Non-Legislative Archive
- ↳ Election Archive
- ↳ Ma'at Law Index
- ↳ Statutory Law Index
- ↳ Treaty Law Index
- ↳ Repealed Law Index
- ↳ Repealed Treaty Index
- ↳ Index Archive
- ↳ Temple of Amun-Ra
- ↳ Convention Announcements
- ↳ Voting Archive
- ↳ Palace of the Pharaoh
- ↳ Hall of the Crowns
- ↳ Hall of the Viziers
- ↳ Chief Vizier's Courtyard
- ↳ Shrine of Apis
- ↳ Shrine of Ma'at
- ↳ Altar of Sobek
- ↳ Hall of the Guardians
- ↳ Palace of the Priests
- ↳ Hall of the Priests
- ↳ Judicial Archive
- ↳ Palace of the Priests
- ↳ Inner Sanctum
- ↳ OFO 1.0
- ↳ Palace of the Pharaoh
- ↳ Royal Throne Room
- ↳ Vizier Courtyard (Vice Pharaoh)
- ↳ Regional Factbook Entries and Information
- ↳ Palace of the Hedjet
- ↳ Temple of Isis (Community Affairs)
- ↳ Shrine of Khnum (Guides)
- ↳ Osiris Job Center
- ↳ Temple of Ptah (Cultural Affairs)
- ↳ Shrine of Thoth (Art)
- ↳ Hapi Bazaar (Marketplace)
- ↳ Temple of Horus (Foreign Affairs)
- ↳ Temple of Seshat (Legal Affairs)
- ↳ Temple of Apis (Media Affairs)
- ↳ Temple of Ma'at (WA Affairs)
- ↳ Shrine of Amun (General Assembly)
- ↳ Shrine of Ra (Security Council)
- ↳ Shrine of Geb (Drafting Assistance)
- ↳ Shrine of Nut (Campaign Assistance)
- ↳ Palace of the Deshret
- ↳ Keeper's Courtyard
- ↳ Detective Figs Law Library
- ↳ Statutory Law Index
- ↳ Treaty Law Index
- ↳ Legislative History Index
- ↳ Library Archive
- ↳ Chamber of the Deshret
- ↳ The People's Palace
- ↳ Voting Archive
- ↳ Legislative Archive
- ↳ Non-Legislative Archive
- ↳ Election Archive
- ↳ Palace of the Pschent
- ↳ Hall of Justice
- ↳ Archives of the Pschent
- ↳ Palace of the Atef
- ↳ Applications Archive
- ↳ Temple of Geb
- ↳ Temple of Shu
- ↳ Temple of Tefnut
- ↳ Temple of Nut
- ↳ Events Archive
- ↳ Euro-Osiris Friendship 2014
- ↳ Games Galore
- ↳ Smorgasbord of Spam
- ↳ Festival of Osiris
- ↳ Festival Spam
- ↳ Festival Games
- ↳ Founding Day Event
- ↳ There's spam!?
- ↳ Games! Booze and games!
- ↳ Festival of the Resurrection 2015
- ↳ The Carnival Tent
- ↳ Festival Grounds
- ↳ The Summer of Love
- ↳ Sandy Wolf Fest '16
- ↳ Festival of the Ancient Gods
- ↳ Pharaoh's Day Festival 2017
- ↳ Coronation Celebration (Syberis)
- ↳ Day 1
- ↳ Day 2
- ↳ Day 3
- ↳ Spam
- ↳ Anubis Treaty Festival
- ↳ Games Galore
- ↳ Spam Central
- ↳ Pharaoh's Day Festival 2018
- ↳ Gazebo
- ↳ History of the Pharaohs
- ↳ Spam Games