[FAILED] Ban on Capital Punishment

Archive of General Assembly proposal discussion threads.

Moderators: Pharaoh, Vizier, Chief Vizier, Sub-Vizier

Post Reply
User avatar
Midnight Sparkle
Posts: 340
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2018 12:00 am
Contact:

[FAILED] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Midnight Sparkle »

Ban on Capital Punishment
Category: Human Rights | Strength: Significant | Proposed by: United Massachusetts
Having already presented its rationale in GA 4XX,

Restating, however, that the death penalty institutionalizes a model of justice with only retributive value, a model inherently flawed in its assertion that violence and killing are best dealt with by more bloodshed,

Concerned that the use of capital punishment prevents nations from taking steps to correct errors in their legal process, the most grave and final sentence having already been delivered,

Believing that life sentences and other alternative punishments better provide criminals with the opportunities to repent for their wrongs and improve their habits,

Asserting that justice is best served without the death penalty, for it is cruel, condemns certain innocent people to death, and rejects the affirmation that all sapient life is valuable by its very existence,

The General Assembly, at long last, invoking its august power in this present session assembled, and by the advice and consent of its delegates and member nations, hereby:
  1. Declares that no member state may execute any person under its jurisdiction.
  2. Mandates that member nations commute any death sentences handed down within their jurisdiction, and instead determine through their legal processes an alternative punishment,
  3. Prohibits member nations from extraditing individuals to a foreign nation where they are likely to face execution or capital punishment inline with prohibited punishment above.
Co-authored by: Imperium Anglorum
Vizier of World Assembly Affairs
User avatar
Midnight Sparkle
Posts: 340
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2018 12:00 am
Contact:

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Midnight Sparkle »

As your Sub-Vizier of WA Affairs/Gameside Affairs, I'd recommend a vote FOR this proposal.
Vizier of World Assembly Affairs
User avatar
JRJR_SLAYER
Posts: 166
Joined: Fri Aug 04, 2017 12:00 am

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by JRJR_SLAYER »

I mean, sure.
User avatar
Ghazia
Citizen
Citizen
Posts: 226
Joined: Thu Aug 17, 2017 12:00 am
Contact:

Badges

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Ghazia »

I have voted NAY, on my WA nation, and I recommend everyone else do so.

The GA's current bill controls your nation's morals, it is telling you that you do not get a choice in whether you can punish your criminals by death. This harms many people who are like me and RP authoritarian and/or super religious empires. My main nation, for example, used to(and does sometimes now) punish heresy. Is that ok irl? no. Is it ok if I am RPing a country like that? yes. and the GA shouldn't be allowed to tell me I can't RP a certain way.

VOTE NAY!
Ghazia-Rahman Ammarah bint Rigel al-Asteorra
She/Her/Hers || Proud Queer Muslim
Trans rights are human rights.
Legion Ribbons
User avatar
Benjabobaria
Posts: 163
Joined: Wed May 09, 2018 12:00 am

Honors

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Benjabobaria »

Executing people is fun, vote against
The Lord Benja Karimi
Son of Khosrow and Sarah, grandson of Lynxi, great-grandson of Altino

Recipient of the Sword of Sekhmet



Former Moshir of the Sekhmet Legion. Join it, raiding is fun!
Spoiler
“Altino” wrote:The number of "Benja this is amazing, I love it!!!" conversations and also "Benja wtf were you thinking, you're ruining my life" conversations we've had go so hard.
Zizou wrote:it's the natives fault for getting beat the fuck up by raiders because the founder cted or they were dumb enough to make the del exec
User avatar
Felt Karpit
Posts: 7
Joined: Fri Aug 03, 2018 12:00 am

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Felt Karpit »

I'm FOR this proposal. Capital punishment is not a viable way of preventing crime.

Also I'm a dumb pacifist that doesn't believe that people have the right to end other's lives, but that's just me
Discord: FeltKarpit #1033
User avatar
PowerPAOK
Posts: 134
Joined: Sat Dec 16, 2017 12:00 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by PowerPAOK »

FOR
TRR's MOST PROLIFIC EX-DOOFA

User avatar
Sygian
Posts: 1421
Joined: Tue Jun 28, 2016 12:00 am

Re: [AT VOTE] Ban on Capital Punishment

Post by Sygian »

For

Sub-Vizier of Foreign Affairs
Patriarch of House Akhenaten
Baron of Koptos
Spoiler
Guardian
Chief Vizier
Chief Scribe
Vizier of WA Affairs (2x)
Forum Administrator
Spoiler
Post Reply

Return to “Shrine of Amun”